Between 1868 and 1869, Robert William Kirkby was a key member of the 18th Regiment’s Band during one of its most illustrious periods in Auckland. Under the leadership of Bandmaster Michael Quinn, the band performed at numerous high-profile events, blending military precision with refined musical artistry. Their performances were not merely regimented duty but also a cultural spectacle that enriched Auckland’s social and musical life. The 18th Regiment’s Band was renowned for its versatility, performing at official military functions, public concerts, theatrical performances, and even private social events. During this period, the band’s presence was indispensable at banquets, balls, and fundraisers, making it a celebrated institution in Auckland’s social and artistic circles.
Michael Quinn, a Kneller Hall-trained musician, had taken over as bandmaster in 1865 and transformed the ensemble into a powerhouse of military music. He composed original pieces and arranged classical works that showcased the band’s technical prowess. The inclusion of orchestral and operatic compositions in the band’s repertoire ensured they remained at the forefront of Auckland’s evolving music scene.
Prominent Performances
Robert Kirkby, as a member of the band, would have played at several notable engagements during this period:
Complimentary Dinners for Naval Officers
The 18th Regiment frequently hosted officers from visiting naval ships at formal dinners. The band provided entertainment at these events, including one on June 5, 1868, for officers of H.M.S. Rosario at the regimental mess-room on Karangahape Road. The regimental band’s "choice selections of popular music" complemented the evening's festivities.
Subscription Balls and Social Gatherings
The band played a central role in Auckland’s private subscription balls, such as the November 12, 1868 ball at the New Music Hall on Symonds Street. Their lively performances included dance pieces like waltzes, galops, quadrilles, and polkas.
Theatrical and Concert Hall Performances
The band regularly participated in theatrical productions and concerts, including a December 19, 1868, event at the Prince of Wales Theatre, where they performed alongside military amateur actors.
Grand Public Concerts
In April 1869, the 18th Regiment Band contributed to the first full symphony performance in Auckland at a Promenade Concert. The program included Mozart’s Symphony No. 1 and other grand orchestral works. The band’s collaboration with the Auckland Choral Society showcased their ability to merge military music with classical repertoire.
A Concert for Royalty
One of the most prestigious events occurred in May 1869, when the band performed at a concert attended by Prince Alfred, Duke of Edinburgh. The prince, an accomplished violinist, played with the orchestra while Quinn conducted. This event cemented the band’s reputation as a premier musical ensemble.
The Final Curtain: Farewell to Auckland
The 18th Regiment’s time in New Zealand came to an end in early 1870. A grand farewell ball was held in February 1870, with the band playing Quinn’s Canary Galop and other dance selections. The regiment departed for Sydney before returning to Great Britain, marking the end of an era for Auckland’s military music scene.
Kirkby’s Role and Legacy
While direct records of Kirkby’s specific performances remain elusive, given his membership in the regiment and the band’s central role in these events, he undoubtedly played at these high-profile engagements. His time with the 18th Regiment Band placed him at the heart of Auckland’s cultural transformation, where military musicians played a pivotal role in shaping the city’s artistic landscape.
Whether in grand symphony performances, theatre productions, or lively military balls, Robert William Kirkby was part of a golden age of regimental music in New Zealand. His tenure with the 18th Regiment’s Band was not just a chapter in his own story but a significant contribution to New Zealand’s early musical history.
For the past few months, I have spent a considerable amount of time reading the muster records of the 18th Royal Irish Regiment to gain a deeper understanding of Robert William Kirkby’s story. This was no small task, as it required reviewing over 3,000 pages of handwritten text. However, I am pleased that my persistence has paid off. As his story unfolded before me, I became even more motivated to uncover additional details.
So, what exactly are Muster Lists? From the early 18th century, regimental musters were conducted on a monthly or quarterly basis for payroll and accounting purposes. These, along with pay lists, served as the primary records of soldiers' active service. The muster rolls and pay lists documented key details such as a soldier's rank, general notes about their movements, and their pay. They also recorded any forfeits and disciplinary actions. These documents played a crucial role in maintaining service records for soldiers in the British Army. However, Muster Lists do not contain physical descriptions of soldiers, nor do they provide detailed information about their exact locations or the battles they participated in. To fill in these gaps, I turned to newspaper articles, diaries, dedicated websites, social media pages, and other sources. Through this research, I have uncovered several intriguing pieces of information. One of the most notable findings is that Robert William Kirkby may have enlisted with the 18th Royal Irish Regiment in Ireland rather than England. It is interesting to consider why he chose to join an Irish regiment. Shortly after the attack on the regiment at Drury by Ngāti Pāoa forces, Robert was promoted from bugler to the rank of Corporal, a position he held during the Battle of Orākau in 1864. However, not long after, he encountered disciplinary issues that led to his confinement before being demoted back to Private.
In December 1867, Robert’s status changed to "non-engaged." A few months later, he joined the 18th Regiment Band, which performed at major events in Auckland. Bandmaster Michael Quinn, a known cricket enthusiast, frequently organized matches, and Robert’s name appears in several newspaper reports documenting his participation. It is possible that Robert became "non-effective" again, which may have ultimately influenced his decision to desert the regiment.
Another intriguing discovery is that Michael Foley, a soldier from the 18th Royal Irish Regiment, also deserted. He fled just two weeks after Robert did. Foley and a man named Kershaw were later involved in an incident at Lake Kimihia, where a third individual, Phillips, drowned. Phillips had previously served as a bugler with the military tram, which could explain their connection.
Mauruuru was the mother of the 5 children of Robert Kershaw. Very little is known about her at all. On the death certificates of her three sons Ned, Puano and Mitai she is listed as:
Mauruuru Pango of Ngati Ruapani
Merita of Ngati Ruapani
Mary Pango
On the 1908 Maori Voters Roll she lists her iwi as Ngati Ruanui, her hapū as Ngaruahine and Ngati Haua (a hapū at Otakeho, Taranaki), her address as Taikatu. Maori Land Court minute book references states she died February 1917 but there is no official death registration. The only record we have so far of her giving evidence in court is the succession to her mothers cousin Waitara, from where our shares in the Ruaotemoko at Normanby derive. Here she states her mother as Ruahau, her brother as Tarawhiti and her sisters as Kaaro& Rangitamoana (the only living sibling at the time). Ngāti Ruapani also has a whakapapa showing her as the daughter of Pango, and that Mauruuru Pango was listed as an owner in the Waikaremoana Block (not lake) in 1908. Later many of our tipuna received debentures.
Uncle Hemi Kohi stated in court that she was of Tuhoe and Ngati Ruanui descent.
Aunty Ngawaina Melbourne especially has been very adamant that we definitely whakapapa to Waikaremoana (see below).
We know there is a connection with Waikato as her sisters Kaaro and Rangitamoana both married back into Huntly. Robert Kershaw served in the Engineer Volunteer Militia in Huntly area between 1873 and 1875. Her eldest son Eruera Matewhitu states Huntly as his birthplace in 1874, also being named after renowned Waikato ancestor Eruera Matewhitu from Taupiri. Her daughter Erana returns to Waikato and marries Kohi Takoro. We know she had whakapapa to Ngati Haua in particular at Otakeho. We know she is buried at Taikatu, where her so Tamou was buried 3 years before her death in 1914.
In the diary of the late Te Awhimate Broughton (née Kershaw) (1894–1964), she made two intriguing notes that may provide significant clues regarding her family's history.
Next to her father’s name, she wrote "Kershaw/Kirkby,, our family" suggesting a possible connection or interchangeability between the two surnames.
She also expressed her wish to be buried "in town by my grandfather Robert Kershaw." At the time she was residing in Hawera, where Robert William Kershaw was buried. There are no registered burial for a Robert Kershaw at the public cemetery records in Taranaki.
Mrs Te Awhimate Broughton
Mrs te Awhimate Broughton died in Hastings last June, aged 72.
Mrs Broughton was the wife of the late George Broughton. During most of their married life they lived in Hawera. Mr Broughton died some 25 years ago.
Mrs Broughton was a daughter of Mr Ned Kershaw, whose grandfather, a Pākehā, fought in the early Māori-Pākehā wars. Her mother was born in Hawkes Bay.
A highly respected member of the community, Mrs Broughton worked hard as a member of the Women’s Tribal Committee.
She is survived by seven children and more than 30 grandchildren.
Tutepourangi McDonald along with Raiha Mohi (nee Kershaw) 1899-1984, wrote her grandfathers name as "Robert William Kirkby, died 19.2.1926, buried Hawera".
In Jeremys granduncles briefcase of whakapapa completed in 1966. Jeremy found whakapapa which lists the death date and burial place for Robert Kershaw that corresponds with Robert William Kirkby death date and burial place. Robert William Kirkby died 19th Feb 1926 at Hawera old mens home and is buried at Hawera Cemetery. In other charts and notes, the names Kershaw or Kirkby or even the full name Robert William Kirkby are given.
I am a great grandson of Materoa Jane Kershaw (later to become a Mrs. MacDonald and Mrs. McGregor). She was born 1901. We were always told that she was Ngāti Porou and Taranaki. After Aunty Rautekura Hill and Aunty Daphne Amokura Moeke started this journey back in 2005, I became heavily involved in trying to piece together the puzzle that is our Kershaw whakapapa.
This journey has taken us across the breadth of the nation. Lil Lmj Tai and I traversed the country in 2009 and met with the likes of Henry Mitai Kershaw, Syd Kershaw, Ngawaina Melbourne, Horace Kohi, Nanny Ellen (nee Kiel), Val Kiel, Tom & Lillian Kershaw, Harvey Tutauha, Hone Nuku-Tarawhiti and Rangipuano Kershaw. We gathered every single bit on information we could.
Uncle Sid Kershaw (Jenny Kershaw) recalls seeing his photo hanging at Te Awhimate Broughton (nee Kershaw) home in Hawera.
During that trek we heard many theories, including but not limited to:
- Robert Kershaw was actually Lord Kirby
- Robert Kershaw was a bugler in the constabularies.
- Robert Kershaw was a deserter.
- Robert Kershaw was infact Robert Kirkby
- Robert Kershaw was a stowaway
- Robert Kershaw was in the 65th regiment
- Robert Kershaw fought at Rangiriri
To this date we have not found any evidence to substantiate these theories. What we do know is very little, including:
- Robert Kershaw served in the Engineer Volunteer Militia in Huntly between 1873-75, they were responsible for the laying of the railway through the Waikato. He served 18 months in this unit as a Corporal. Sadly the records of the EVM in Waikato did not survive and we can only rely on the information provided in the constabulary records about previous service, and this newspaper article which speaks about his involvement in a coronary inquest: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspape…/WT18741107.2.12…
- Robert Kershaw served in the army constabulary from 4.10.1881 to 20.11.1881, discharged at Taranaki. He was present at the government invasion of Parihaka on 5.11.1881. This was the last 'active service' of the constabulary, and the soldiers were then divided into Police and Military Field Force in 1886. Details state:
Date of Appointment: 4.1.81
Date of Swearing in 4.10.81
Born in: England
Occupation: Labourer
Age: 35 (birthdate 1846)
Height: 5'7"
Complexion: Fresh
Hair: Fair
Eyes: Blue
Married or Single: Single
Religion: Church of England
Previous Service, if any: Engineer Voluntary Militia
Remarks: Discharged at Taranaki about 30.4.84 (this part was very faded).
- Robert Kershaw is registered as a Constable at Pungarehu, Taranaki at 9 Nov. 1882, this is substantiated by this newspaper article: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspape…/TH18821109.2.13…
- 18.5.1885 Robert Kershaw is again registered in the Constabularies, he is discharged at Wellington on 7.5.1888 after 2 years and 8 months service.
- On 3.8.1886 there is a record of a Robert Kershaw in Masterton, this is substantiated by both newspapers and electoral rolls: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newsp…/WAIST18861006.2.10…
- On 2.3.1899, Robert Kershaw states he is living at Tempsky Road, Okaiawa, it is also stated he is a lodger at the Okaiawa Hotel: https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspap…/HNS18990302.2.23…
- From 1896 - 1919, Robert Kershaw, Labourer appears on the Voters Roll as living at Okaiawa, later moving to Katotauru Road, Okaiawa from 1911 to 1919.
- Te Awhimate Broughton (nee Kershaw) (1894 - 1964) states in her diary her wish to be buried 'in town by my grandfather, Robert Kershaw' when she was still living in Hawera. The closest we have found is a Robert Kirkby who died in 1926, and is buried at Hawera.
There is no other records about Robert Kershaw. There is no evidence that he ever lived with Mauruuru for long.
We do not have solid evidence as to whether he was from Lancashire or Yorkshire. We know nothing before 1873. It is hoped that we may be able to delve further, and we are awaiting archives from England for Robert Kershaws born in 1846.
As you can imagine this is quite costly, so all proceeds from book sales go back to the research pool to help alleviate costs.
The mystery remains, who was Robert Kershaw?
On the 26th October 2019 a 3 day wananga to commemorate the only daughter of Robert Kershaw & Mauruuru – Erana who married Kohi Takoro, from whom descend our Kohi whānau. It was a great opportunity to meet our Waikato connection and to unveil a memorial commemorating Erana and Kohi Takoro who are buried at Pepepe Urupā.